Limitations and Misconceptions | Origin: EL113
This is a general discussion forum for the following learning topic:
Active Learning in an Online Environment --> Limitations and Misconceptions
Post what you've learned about this topic and how you intend to apply it. Feel free to post questions and comments too.
There are some misconceptions about active learning like the instructor will loose control over the class or that they should not make the class entertainment. However, this has been shown to have the best engagement from students and gives everyone other ways to remember things since everyone learns differently. While it is ultimately up to the student to complete their work and to learn the material, by offering class in different formats it gives the student more opportunities to learn.
Active learning can sometimes be limited but only to those that want to see it that way. Active learning can be fun and engage the students more and make the student retain information much easier.
Without real time, in person interaction personalize feedback can be difficult.
This module reminds us that there are many different types of learning, traditional and non-traditional, and often it is a blend of many different methods and techniques that is best. We need to be open to new ideas and keep our students' best interests in mind.
In this module, I was reminded that active learning isn’t just a set of techniques, it’s a mindset shift toward making students responsible participants in their own understanding. The emphasis on strategies like case analysis, concept mapping, peer discussion, and quick knowledge checks helped me see how small, intentional moments of engagement can dramatically change how students process information.
I plan to apply this by building more structured opportunities for students to pause, think, and articulate their reasoning. That might include adding brief concept checks during lectures, using pairs to break up dense content, or incorporating short case scenarios that require students to connect ideas rather than memorize them. My goal is to create learning spaces where students stay mentally active, feel ownership over the material, and get immediate feedback that helps them grow.
I am a big fan of active learning because, in my opinion, most students out there now lean towards the non traditional student. They learn by doing and actively engaging with manipulatives and each other. I used to compete with Sesame Street type stimulation where there was music and fun for every concept, now instructors compete with fast moving UTube videos and social media. Taking the time to make the concepts fun and engaging is well worth the instructor's time, especially in career courses where active application of skills is part of the plan.
Active learning improves engagement and retention, but may overwhelm students and require more time and preparation.
This module helped me understand that while active learning is highly effective, it also comes with limitations and common misconceptions—especially in online environments. One major misconception is that active learning means the instructor loses control of the class. In reality, the instructor’s role shifts from being the “sage on the stage” to a facilitator who guides, structures, and supports learning. When done well, active learning is actually more intentional and structured, not less .
Another misconception is that students will automatically engage or be prepared to take responsibility for their learning. In practice, some students may resist active learning because it requires more effort, accountability, and participation. This can sometimes be interpreted as a weakness of the method, when in fact it highlights the need for clear expectations, guidance, and support.
The module also highlighted several real limitations, such as:
Time and effort required for instructors to design meaningful activities
Technology challenges in online environments (platform issues, access, reliability)
Potential inequities, where some students may struggle more due to access or skill gaps
The need for a backup plan when technology fails
What stood out to me is that active learning is most effective when it is well-planned and balanced. It’s not about making everything interactive, but about choosing strategies that truly support learning outcomes.
Going forward, I plan to apply this by:
Setting clear expectations so students understand their role in active learning
Designing structured activities that guide participation rather than leaving it open-ended
Preparing backup options in case of technology issues
Providing support and feedback to help students adjust to this learning style
Being flexible and recognizing that not all students will engage the same way
Overall, I now see active learning as a shared responsibility between instructor and student. When both are engaged and supported, it leads to deeper understanding and more meaningful learning experiences.
active learning can be an effective tool.
The students will retain the information better when they aren't force fed.
there are positive and negatives of active learning but when utilized correctly the student has a true understanding of the subject vs the ability to regurgitate the information
It is important for instructors to have flexibility in their teaching style. Setting expectations for quality of work can help emphasize that while I am trying to make learning fun and engaging, it is still work and requires commitment.
Recognizing that online environments can still be active, collaborative classrooms is key to a successful online course. Taking the time to plan a structured lesson with multiple ways for the students to learn and show their learning is important for everyone, the teacher and the students.
Proper instruction in active learning techniques prepares instructors for success.
Active learning has a potential to be inequitable
Active learning will require more effort from the instructor but is well worth it because ultimately, the learning is the student's reward and responsibility. There will be technological challenges in an online active learning environment, so it is imperative to have easily accessible resources available to the students and instructors to manage these challenges.
Comment on Catherine Holtman's post: Comment on Shahid Hussain's post: I agree with your statement that there is a significant initial time investment for the instructor to adapt prior material that was used in the traditional classroom to incorporate into the online experience. For this to work well for all involved, I believe that the instructor should receive an incentive and/or be appropriately compensated for their time.
There might be disruptions with the technology being used and it's always good to have a "Plan b."
The instructor must ensure that the technology is working prior to class as technology can add to the students' frustration if it not working on the instructor's part or the student. Using active learning the students will take the initiative in their learning.
