As a welding instructor a rubric is nice to have as the students don't understand welding code but that is my standard for them passing a weld test. And testing often is my way of assessment.
Using the rubric provides a ton of guidance when evaluating each students performance. It does allow for much margin of error.
Instructors are to reinforce to students the importance of adhering to following the rubric. I've noticed often students don't look at the rubric or only use the parts they are willing to address in assignments. When they get low scores, they are angry.
Comment on Omar Muneeb's post:
The rubric is a great tool for assessing knowledge students can apply to real-life experiences.
Rubrics can be helpful, but sometimes a more open ended approach is needed.
Evaluating student progress takes time!
Have multiple areas (problem solving, factual knowledge, technical skills, attitude) to assess our students is so important, and honestly fair to the student. Some are plagued by performance nerves, some by test anxiety, it doesnt mean they wont be a great clinician or be a value to the field.
Emphasize Lab safety by showing "What NOT to do" videos.
Comment on Laura Hogins's post: yes we use the ruburic
The best test for competency is to ask the students critical thinking questions.
How to grade my students labs
An effective assessment should cover all the 3 domains of cognitive, affective and psychomotor. Lab assessments can be tough, as it can be time consuming as well as exhausting. Competency assessment tests performance more than the knowledge and we should make sure that we assess all the 3 following: 1. foundation skills, 2. technical skills, 3. professional skills. Rubric is an important tool and can help in better assessment.
In the course I teach, it requires constant evaluation, because the students are applying skills learned while performing what they have learned. The grading Rubic is a good for the student to see what the grading differences are and how to improve.
I can not agree more with Mr. Taylor
The instructor / teacher needs complete control and total understanding of the resources and task in the lab. If not no grading box chart in the world will help students get the proper feedback about their skills.
It will take some critical thinking to apply these new evaluation concepts to my competency assessments.
Reply to Michael Taylor's post:Reply to Michael Taylor's post: Good post. I would like to know more about how you evaluate. Some sucess stories and some failures. Thank you
I have seen a Principal use the evaluation method of observable and measureable in my classroom evaluation and now I know where to build a good base to meet that expectation. Good topic for discussion. Can someone tell me a good rubric they use in their classroom?
Makln sUte the students understand what you are looking for at the beginning of the class on how to wire their project thur out the term.
I would love to hear from soeone who has a good rubric for Building Trades 1
The rubric is a great tool to help evaluate students learning
