Hi Nancy, I should clarify when I said I was working with the student. She wanted to do extra work so she could pass and I explained that extra work was not the issue but it was as you say "quality of work" and with her absences there was not enough quality. So I am recommending she take the course over again to gain the knowledge and skills. I cannot pass her with extra work since that would be the out many of the students would chose. A great way to pass a class come a couple of times due a little extra work and then pass. I don't think so on my watch. I agree with your position and statements in relation to work and rewards. Gary